Home Body & Wellness A Doctor Cracked One Hand for Fifty Years to Settle This

A Doctor Cracked One Hand for Fifty Years to Settle This

0
19

General information, not medical advice. Persistent joint pain, swelling or stiffness should be assessed by a doctor.

Donald Unger’s mother told him that cracking his knuckles would give him arthritis. He decided to find out.

For the next fifty years he cracked the knuckles of his left hand at least twice a day — somewhere north of 36,500 cracks — while leaving his right hand strictly alone. In 1998 he published the result as a letter in Arthritis & Rheumatism: no arthritis in either hand, and no apparent difference between them.

In 2009 he received the Ig Nobel Prize in Medicine for it. The prize citation describes more than sixty years of cracking, which is where the commonly quoted figure comes from; the paper itself reports fifty. Eleven years had passed, and he had not stopped.

It is a wonderful piece of work and it is also the weakest evidence on this question. One subject, unblinded, self-assessed, no radiographs reported, conducted by a man with an obvious stake in the answer. The reason the conclusion holds is that three proper studies reached it independently.

The actual evidence

The largest is Kevin deWeber’s 2011 case-control study in the Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine, which examined 215 people aged 50 to 89 who had a hand radiograph on file — 135 with diagnosed osteoarthritis and 80 controls. Twenty per cent were habitual knuckle crackers.

Hand osteoarthritis, by cracking status deWeber et al. 2011, n=215 Knuckle crackers 18.1% Non-crackers 21.5% P = 0.548 — no difference, and if anything the wrong way round. What did predict it, in the same study Family history of hand OA — odds ratio 2.98 (P = 0.009) Age — odds ratio 1.20 per year (P = 0.001) Knuckle cracking — not significant (P = 0.626)

Osteoarthritis in any hand joint occurred in 18.1% of crackers against 21.5% of non-crackers, P = 0.548. Nothing reached significance for any individual joint type, and neither the duration of the habit nor its cumulative volume made a difference.

Worth noting, since you will sometimes see one quoted: the paper reports no odds ratio for knuckle cracking. It was simply not significant in the regression. The odds ratios it does report are for family history and age — the things that actually drive hand arthritis.

Earlier work points the same way. Robert Swezey surveyed elderly nursing-home residents in 1975 and found no correlation between cracking and degenerative change at the knuckle joints; if anything the association ran mildly in the opposite direction, which in a sample of 28 is noise rather than a finding, whatever some websites have built on it.

The one positive result

This is the study most often left out, and it deserves its place.

Jorge Castellanos and David Axelrod examined 300 consecutive patients aged 45 and over for the Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases in 1990 — 74 habitual crackers, with an average habit of some 35 years, against 226 non-crackers.

They confirmed no excess arthritis. But they found crackers were more likely to have hand swelling and lower grip strength, and concluded that habitual knuckle cracking results in functional hand impairment.

Two caveats. The finding has not been replicated in the 35 years since. And the authors themselves noted that cracking travelled with manual labour, nail biting, smoking and drinking — any of which could explain a grip-strength difference in a cross-sectional sample. Causal direction is unestablished.

Still, the accurate summary is “no arthritis,” not “no effect.”

What the noise actually is

Not bone against bone, and not tendons. It is a gas cavitation event in the synovial fluid, and the joint visibly comes apart when it happens.

Unsworth, Dowson and Wright established the mechanics in 1971 by pulling on people’s fingers with measured force. Cracks occurred at tensile loads between 10 and 16 kilograms. In one finger the joint gap went from 0.98 mm at rest to 2.50 mm at the instant of the crack, recovering to 1.40 mm after five minutes and back to baseline by fifteen. High-speed film showed the whole event taking about a hundredth of a second.

That also explains the refractory period. You cannot re-crack a knuckle immediately; it takes roughly twenty minutes, while the gas redissolves and the ligaments and cartilage recover their shape.

An argument that is still open

What remains genuinely disputed is which half of the bubble’s life makes the sound.

Unsworth’s team concluded it was the collapse of the vapour bubble, not its formation.

In 2015, Gregory Kawchuk’s group put a finger in an MRI scanner and filmed it. Joint separation went from 0.93 mm to 1.89 mm, and a cavity appeared at the moment of separation — and, they reported, was never seen to collapse. They concluded the sound comes from cavity formation, through a process called tribonucleation. This was widely reported as having overturned the old account.

It is one subject, ten joints, and the scanner ran at 3.2 frames per second against an event lasting around ten milliseconds.

Three years later, Vineeth Chandran Suja and Abdul Barakat built a mathematical model of the acoustics in Scientific Reports and reached the opposite conclusion — that only a partial collapse of the bubble is needed to reproduce the observed sound, which would leave a stable microbubble behind. In other words, a cavity still visible on MRI is not evidence that no collapse occurred. Their model predicts a peak around 83 decibels at roughly 129 Hz, and that the pitch rises sharply with joint load.

Their model also under-predicts the later acoustic peaks, and rests on assumed inputs. So: the mechanism is unsettled, not resolved — which is a more honest thing to say than either side’s press coverage managed.

The bottom line

Three independent studies across 36 years, using different designs and different populations, found no association between knuckle cracking and hand osteoarthritis. What predicts hand arthritis is family history and age.

No prospective trial exists and none is likely, so a small effect cannot be excluded. One unreplicated study found reduced grip strength. And nobody can yet agree on what makes the noise.

Your mother was wrong about the arthritis. She may have had other reasons for asking you to stop.

Sources